cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - Have a PTC product question you need answered fast? Chances are someone has asked it before. Learn about the community search. X

One Mathcad Case

ValeryOchkov
24-Ruby IV

One Mathcad Case

This is not my fantasy (as some others cases here) - this is a real case from my practice.
I often consult my colleagues at my University (not only) with Mathcad questions.

There was a case!
One of my colleagues come to me and shows me a calculation result of something like this in Mathcad his worksheet.

See please http://communities.ptc.com/message/176380

http://communities.ptc.com/servlet/JiveServlet/downloadImage/2-176380-28822/76-31/326.png
This man told me that when he saw this answer, he has saved it and restarted his Mathcad. The answer was the same - wrong. This man decided that his Mathcad corrupted and reinstalled it. The answer was the same - wrong. Then the man has deleted new version of Mathcad, deciding that it was false, and installed on your computer the old version of Mathcad ("The best wine comes out of an old vessel"). But the answer was the same - wrong.

Than this man began to decide - where to go - to a psychiatrist or to me. Fortunately, he decided to go to me. And I was able to explain to this man, what was his mistake.

And you would be able to explain it!?

Or welcome to the Mathcad House - http://communities.ptc.com/groups/mathcad-paradoxes

3 REPLIES 3

Mark Twain.
From the story "HOW I EDITED AN AGRICULTURAL PAPER ONCE" see - http://www.twainquotes.com/Galaxy/187007a.html

Pretty soon after this a long, cadaverous creature, with lanky locks hanging down to his shoulders and a week's stubble bristling from the hills and valleys of his face, darted within the door, and halted, motionless, with finger on lip, and head and body bent in listening attitude. No sound was heard. Still he listened. No sound. Then he turned the key in the door, and came elaborately tip-toeing toward me, till he was within long reaching distance of me, when he stopped, and, after scanning my face with intense interest for a while, drew a folded copy of our paper from his bosom, and said:

"There -- you wrote that. Read it to me, quick! Relieve, me -- I suffer."

I read as follows -- and as the sentences fell from my lips I could see the relief come -- I could see the drawn muscles relax, and the anxiety go out of the face, and rest and peace steal over the features like the merciful moonlight over a desolate landscape:

The guano is a fine bird, but great care is necessary in rearing it. It should not be imported earlier than June nor later than September. In the winter it should be kept in a warm place, where it can hatch out its young. It is evident that we are to have a backward season for grain. Therefore, it will be well for the farmer to begin setting out his corn-stalks and planting his buckwheat cakes in July instead of August.

Concerning the Pumpkin. -- This berry is a favorite with the natives of the interior of New England, who prefer it to the gooseberry for the making of fruit cake, and who likewise give it the preference over the raspberry for feeding cows, as being more filling and fully as satisfying. The pumpkin is the only esculent of the orange family that will thrive in the North, except the gourd and one or two varieties of the squash. But the custom of planting it in the front !yard with the shrubbery is fast going out of vogue, for it is now generally conceded that the pumpkin, as a shade tree, is a failure.

Now, as the warm weather approaches, and the ganders begin to spawn --

The excited listener sprang toward me, to shake hands, and said:

"There, there -- that will do! I know I am all right now because you have read it just as I did, word for word. But, stranger, when I first read it this morning I said to myself I never, never believed it before, notwithstanding my friends kept me under watch so strict, but now I believe I am crazy; and with that I fetched a howl that you might have heard two miles, and started out to kill somebody -- because, you know, I knew it would come to that sooner or later, and so I might as well begin. I read one of them paragraphs over again, so as to be certain, and then I burned my house down and started I have crippled several people, and have got one fellow up a tree, where I can get him if I want him. But I thought I would call in here as I passed along, and make the thing perfectly certain; and now it is certain, and I tell you it is lucky for the chap that is in the tree. I should have killed him, sure, as I went back. Good-by, sir, good-by -- you have taken a great load off my mind. My reason has stood the strain of one of your agricultural articles, and I know that nothing can ever unseat it now . Good-by, sir."

Is your esteemed colleague using a Student Licence?

That could be the problem! My Student Licence returns the same answer as your colleague's.

Top Tags