topic Dynamic milling like MasterCAM? in System Administration

Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

snguyen — Sun, 13 Dec 2020 21:02:23 GMT

Good morning, It was brought to my attention by a new coworker that use toprogram using MasterCAM on how to improve our machining process. He showedme some videos of the Dynamic milling and it looked really fast andefficient. Would anybody that is using Creo Manufacturing

RE: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

NickMihelich — Wed, 29 Apr 2015 15:08:45 GMT

when this happens you will be very happy.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

blong — Fri, 01 May 2015 11:58:40 GMT

Yea it does not do it at all at this time. We have been asking and waiting for years.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

sbarnett — Fri, 08 May 2015 04:59:40 GMT

It is a shame how PTC has allowed Pro Mfg too fall behind other cam systems.

I have to use Mastercam X6 for my Dynamic Milling.

By the way PTC what happened to the Live material removal you promised to be in Creo 3 ?

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

ArtinB — Fri, 08 May 2015 16:33:34 GMT

There is a plug-in (Modular) for Creo called VoluMill that will do similar to Dynamic Milling and works good.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

RussellMcMahon — Thu, 28 May 2015 20:08:24 GMT

I am a former Mastercam user, and I really miss it. I have been using Creo for the last 2 years. Creo truely is behind the times for dynamic milling. The only thing close in Creo is Volume with constant load. VoluMill does have an stand alone platform that works great but have yet to coordinated with PTC to have a plug and play module that works in Creo.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

snguyen — Wed, 17 Jun 2015 19:27:46 GMT

I have been playing with original volume mill and can almost get the same results like Dynamic milling. The only thing I can not figure out is on the start of the sequence the tool will always go to X0 Y0 twice and then goes to machining the constant load rough option. It is actually working pretty good but that crazy X0 Y0 at the start of the tool path. Example of code below notice the X0. Y0. and then on line N70 X0. Y0. Z2.

%
O0001 (CONSTANT_LOAD)
(PROGRAM REVISION: -)
(THIS REQUIRES ZERO IN TOOL REGISTER FOR TOOL DIAMETER)

(THIS IS A HAAS PROGRAM)

N10 G40 G80 G90 G17

(TOOL 3 OFFSET 3)
(.5" DIA. 3 FLT CARB BULLMILL W.03" RAD)
(RGH MILL WIND)

N20 M6 T3
N30 G0 G54 X0. Y0. S10000 M3
N40 G43 Z2. H03 M8
N50 G1 Z2.031 F500.
N60 X-.9508 Y1.325 Z.141
N70 X0. Y0. Z2.
N80 X-.9508 Y1.325 Z.21
N90 Z.11 F300.
N100 X-.961 Y1.3319 Z.062

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

RussellMcMahon — Wed, 17 Jun 2015 19:52:53 GMT

it sounds like your post is set to output CSYS zero location

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

snguyen — Wed, 17 Jun 2015 20:12:15 GMT

But if I change to a spiral or any other volume mill sequence it does not do that.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

jternák — Tue, 30 Jun 2015 19:52:38 GMT

Dear Artin,

my information is mid 2016 come the Creo 4 and PTC will with VoluMill put in the new Roughing technology.

But interest me how to function the plug-in.

Have you any information?

thanks your answer.

János Ternák.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

jternák — Wed, 01 Jul 2015 06:45:40 GMT

Dear Son nguyen,

I heard so the hypermill can link with Creo, but it means you need to buy Creo NC and hypermill too.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

ArtinB — Wed, 01 Jul 2015 21:12:46 GMT

When VoluMill is installed it will create a tab (menu) in CREO/manufacturing, that you can use it to generate roughing sequence.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

ToddWoodall — Mon, 06 Jul 2015 15:17:50 GMT

I have been using the constant load option a lot recently and have gotten good results. I visited the Creo NC Booth at PTC live and was made aware of two parameters that help.

MIN_RETRACT_DISTANCE is actually the distance that you desire between retracts. if you want the tool to stay down set this to a value larger than the area or (part) that you are machining.

LIFT_TOOL_CLEARANCE is a value to lift the tool when not in cut (like a small retract).

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

SteveLucas — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 13:47:11 GMT

Todd,

I have been playing with those parameters and still get a retract at the wall but not all the time ? I have a pocket similar to your second picture that I am trying to cut. It is a .125 deep by .500 wide by 3 inch long pocket but the cutter still retracts back to z zero for a ways then settles down and behaves as expected. I guess this is a work in progress I can't figure it out. I used the parameters similar to what you have in your picture but that must have been for the one that retracted all the time.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

BillChapman — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 13:58:16 GMT

Todd,

These sequences look nice. Would it be possible for you to save the ncsequence parameters file for these programs?

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

snguyen — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 14:20:19 GMT

Been playing around with constant load in Creo 3.0 M040 and it has been working really good with those parameters but be careful with gouging. I have a case filed with ptc support case #12437221. PTC has been able to replicate the situation in M040 and M050. The work around so far, to prevent the gouging when the tool is doing a traverse move is to create multiple windows and try to keep the windows as simplest as you can and it will not gouge the part. I did not see the gouge until I ran it in Vericut lite. I can also send you the .mil for you to play with but then the sequence will not be driven by the tool and material.

The extra retract moves will happen sometimes and sometime work like a charm.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

ToddWoodall — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 16:40:40 GMT

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

SteveLucas — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 17:34:47 GMT

Todd,

Thanks for sending the Parameters. I see the difference now. You are using volume milling. I was trying to use the roughing sequence.works now!

I wish PTC would do a little more for us with tutorials or training for the new parameters and sequence options. Seasoned users of Creo are not going to take a class or get a subscription to PTC U just to get up to speed with the new stuff.

Steve

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

SteveLucas — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 17:40:34 GMT

Son,

I downloaded your files and did a play path before looking at the parameters in your crash file sequence. I thought when it gouged I bet he doesn't have retract set to always.

then I looked and sure enough it was set to always in the parameters. Sure looks like a software bug to me.

I had the same issue when we tried Pro toolmaker. it would not retract and gouged all over the place for me. I hope they get this issue fixed soon.

Re: Dynamic milling like MasterCAM?

ToddWoodall — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 18:41:19 GMT

I actually picked that up at PTC Live in the Creo NC Help Booth. I agree that this product is not very well supported. I think we may see more in Creo 4.0.